What Is a Contingency Fee, and Should I Pay One?

A contingency fee is a payment arrangement in which your lawyer’s fee is a percentage of whatever you recover from the case, and zero if you don’t recover anything. Used in personal injury, employment discrimination, wage and hour claims, and several other plaintiff-side practice areas.

Standard contingency rates

In the United States, the typical contingency rate is 33⅓% (one third) if the case settles before a lawsuit is filed, rising to 40% if a lawsuit is filed, and sometimes 45% if the case actually goes to trial.

Some states cap contingency fees in specific case types. New York caps medical malpractice contingency fees on a sliding scale (30% of the first $250,000, declining percentages above). Florida has similar caps. Most states do not cap contingency fees outside specific contexts.

Who pays the case expenses

Separately from the lawyer’s fee, every case has expenses — filing fees, deposition costs, expert witness fees, record retrieval, copy costs, and so on. In a routine personal injury case, expenses might run $1,500–$5,000. In a complex case with multiple expert witnesses, $50,000+ is normal.

Two ways expenses are usually handled:

1. Lawyer advances expenses, recoups from settlement. The default in personal injury work. The expenses are deducted from your share after the lawyer’s fee.
2. Client pays expenses as they come due. Less common; usually only in cases the lawyer thinks are weak.

Read the fee agreement carefully. Some firms calculate the contingency fee on the gross recovery (before expenses), others on the net (after expenses). The difference can be significant.

A worked example

You suffer a back injury in a car accident. The other driver’s insurer ultimately pays $90,000. Your lawyer agreed to a 33% contingency, with expenses of $4,000 deducted first.

• If gross fee: Lawyer fee = $30,000. Expenses = $4,000. Your share = $56,000.
• If net fee: Expenses = $4,000 first. Net = $86,000. Lawyer fee = $28,400. Your share = $57,600.

A 4% difference at $90,000 — modest. At $1.5M, the same percentage difference is $60,000. Always confirm which method your fee agreement uses.

When contingency makes sense for you

• You can’t afford to pay hourly fees up front
• Your case has real upside but also real risk
• You want the lawyer to have skin in the game
• Hourly billing would equal or exceed the likely fee anyway

When contingency might not make sense

• You have a near-certain win on a small recovery (the lawyer collects 33% even though the work was minimal)
• You can comfortably afford hourly billing and your case is straightforward
• The defendant has limited assets — the lawyer may not work hard on a case unlikely to pay

What’s negotiable

A lot. Lawyers don’t volunteer this, but contingency rates are absolutely negotiable, especially in:

• High-value cases ($500K+) where 33% would be a windfall
• Cases the lawyer is eager to take (clear liability, large insurer)
• Repeat-client situations
• Sliding-scale arrangements (e.g., 25% up to $X, 33% above)

You can also negotiate the expenses cap, the calculation method (gross vs net), and the right to cancel without owing fees if you fire the lawyer early.

What you should sign and when

Never sign a fee agreement at the consultation, in the hospital, or under any time pressure. Take it home, read it, and ask:

1. What percentage at each stage (pre-suit, post-suit, trial)?
2. Is the percentage on gross or net?
3. Who advances expenses?
4. Are expenses capped?
5. What happens if I fire you?
6. What happens if you withdraw?
7. Are there any non-contingency fees (“administrative fees,” “file opening fees”)?

If the answers don’t satisfy you, there’s another lawyer who’ll do better. Personal injury especially is competitive — you’re not stuck.

---

This article describes general U.S. contingency fee practice. State rules vary. Consult a lawyer in your jurisdiction about your specific case.