Melissa J Winthers

A very grateful client · personal injury · May 2026

I was injured in an automobile accident when my car was hit while at a stop. For a while after that incident I thought I could handle everything on my own but as the months went by and I wasn’t getting any better and the insurance companies were not helpful I realized that wasn’t the case and decide d to enlist some help. This wasn’t an easy decision to make and finding the right attorney was no simple task. Yes there are many to be found but after meeting with several I started to doubt my decision. I was extremely fortunate though when a friend referred me to Melissa Winthers of Fleishman & Shapiro P.C. From my initial phone call into their office I could already tell I was in good hands and after meeting with Melissa for the first time I knew I had found the most qualified and best attorney to help me with my case. Throughout my entire experience with Melissa and Gina Powell (paralegal) I was treated with respect, honesty and true concern about how I was doing. Every single phone call of mine was returned with extreme promptness, every question I had was answered quickly with all the information I needed. I was always informed of what was happening with my case, the details of the process every step of the way and what to expect each time we moved forward. I never felt insignificant as a client or unprepared for any aspect of my case. Melissa always explained everything to me without fluffing the truth or painting a picture she felt I needed to hear. She was always honest, extremely resourceful and pragmatic but at the same time kind-hearted, empathetic and extremely passionate about helping. Gina also made sure that I had everything I needed (documents, answers, strong shoulder and big ear) and always took the time to make sure I was “okay” during the process. She deserves a medal for her organization and hand-holding skills that no doubt helped me make it through the process in one piece. In the end Melissa was successful in producing a very respectable settlement for my case. To say I’m pleased would be an understatement. I never would have accomplished this on my own or (in my opinion) if I had hired another attorney. Her passion is her driving force, her knowledge in this arena can’t be rivaled and this is what makes her stand well above the rest. I hope I never need her services again but if I did find myself with an injury from another automobile accident I wouldn’t even consider retaining anyone else.

Diahnna · personal injury · May 2026

I was involved in a life altering accident. Melissa Winthers was my legal representative. Throughout my case Melissa kept me well informed, stood by me through numerous hurdles, and was a tremendous support when I needed encouraging. My case recently settled, and I am very pleased with the outcome du e to her hard work and commitment.

Pat · personal injury · May 2026

My parent was involved in a pedestrian/car accident and was incapacitated. There were five insurance companies involved. I tried going it on my own for a while until I hit a dead end and it became apparent that I needed legal assistance. It became very complicated; there was a lot of paperwork and it became clear that one insurance company in particular was playing me since I did not know the law and did not have representation. I telephone-interviewed several Denver firms; then personally interviewed three, and in the end Melissa Winthers came out ahead. Lucky me. I made the right choice! From the very beginning of our relationship, Melissa listened to me and what I wanted. She worked within those parameters, and never once tried to oversell me. It was complex and took time. I had no experience in these matters, but I had made some progress on my own with some of the insurers so it was important to me that she start in the middle. She did exactly that which demonstrated her integrity. The other attorney’s I interviewed were unwilling to do this which highlighted that they prioritized their own interest over resolving my dispute. She treated me fairly and billed honestly. She acted as my advisor with some insurers and my attorney of record with others. There was a lawsuit and arbitration and she worked with me practically in resolving these conflicts. I consider myself very lucky to have had the Universe point me in Melissa's direction at the right time. I would highly recommend her to anybody involved in an injury claim against an insurance company and in dealing with the Medicare bureaucracy. Melissa provided me as her client, exactly what I needed, when I needed it, honestly and fairly. There is no better professional compliment than that!

anonymous · personal injury · May 2026

I was involved in a car accident in 2012, having several injuries. Melissa was wonderful. When she took over my case, I was very relieved. She took all of the stress off, having to deal with insurance companies. Melissa was very compassionate and kind, always checking on how I was doing. She was very knowledgeable and had great advice when I asked. Melissa always returned phone calls and emails, and continually kept me updated on my case. She gave me the time I needed to try several medical options, and I never felt pressured to settle my case. When I was ready to settle, she helped me get a fair settlement. I am eternally grateful for all Melissa and her team and all they did for my family and I.

Anton · personal injury · May 2026

I was involved in a motorcycle accident in another state, just prior to moving to Colorado. I had hired a firm, based in yet another state, who advertised themselves as "Bikers helping bikers". I assumed that they might have additional insight and experience, relative to my particular situation, so I went with them. After a very short time of dealing with this firm, it was obvious that I had made a terrible choice! Having never being in need of an attorney prior to this accident, I was not well versed in the selection process. Aside from not having a face to face relationship with my attorney, I was unable to speak to anyone other than the receptionist and had to make numerous calls requesting a conference. When he finally did return my call it was generally several days later. Mellisa was recommended to me by my chiropractor, and it turned out to be very fortunate and the best decision I could have made, not only because of the issues I was having with my first choice, but for the excellent attention and obvious abilities exhibited by Melissa and her support staff. Melissa's knowledge of head injuries was very impressive, equal to her extensive abilities in the legal profession. Their combined efforts resulted in a very favorable outcome and I would highly recommend Melissa Winthers to anyone who finds themselves in the unfortunate position of requiring legal help. She is definitely one of "the good guys!"